Showing posts with label hate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label hate. Show all posts

Saturday, September 30, 2017

What I Am Thinking

As many of you who know me already are aware, I am a flag-waving, liberal-radical patriot who loves this country and what we have stood for over these 240+ years. I take off my hat and stand for the National Anthem and Stars and Stripes Forever sends chills up my spine. I follow the sentiment of the one-time Watertown, WI, Republican and Civil War veteran, Carl Schurz in
“My country, right or wrong; if right, to be kept right; and if wrong, to be set right.”
(Yes, this is about to be a post on the NFL protests and tempest in a teapot.)

My first reaction can be stated simply, but not without a little length:
  • No one protests or threatens to turn off the NFL when it is about
    • Domestic abusers and batterers getting a simple slap on the wrist;
    • An NFL superstar bumping and pushing an officer with his car in the Twin Cities;
    • A history of concussions and intentional "illegal" hits and tackles;
This doesn't even take into account the exorbitant ticket costs and millionaire players being paid by billionaire owners. That is simply American business practices.

But the past week or so the whole issue of players protesting
  • systematic racism
has exploded into a huge controversy threatening
  • boycotts, 
  • lower ticket sales, 
  • attacks on the right of free speech, 
  • threats of getting fired in NASCAR, and 
  • the President of the United States turning it into a firestorm by calling the protestors "sons of bitches" when he couldn't say anything about Nazi organizers but that they had some "good people."
One would think that the very foundation of our nation is being attacked.

And it is, but not by the protestors.

Suddenly it is claimed the protests are disgraceful behavior, disrespecting veterans, contempt for the flag, and an insult to the National Anthem. As if waving the confederate battle flag isn't disrespecting my great-uncle who died at the Battle of the Wilderness as a Union (United States) soldier. Oops..no, that's heritage.

Meanwhile the results of three hurricanes are causing suffering and illness to millions in three different parts of the USA and our people.

Meanwhile most of us white Americans have great difficulty seeing how our privilege, based on our color, doesn't allow for the growth opportunities for many who are not.

Meanwhile we are closing our borders and our minds to the freedom of religion, calling hateful actions by Nazis "free speech", and Colin Kaepernick's and the NFL's peaceful protests anti-American.
  • How have we managed to go so far downhill away from our values and promises? 
  • How have we managed to allow ourselves to be sold a bill of goods that being American is to be white and European only? 
  • How have we permitted attacks on racism to become attacks on the country?
  • How have many who call themselves Christian been lulled into thinking that hatred and prejudice and discrimination are answers to that question, "What would Jesus do?"
 I keep waiting to wake up and find it is all a nightmare or some dystopian vision of an American that could be, but isn't. I keep praying that it is not too late.

I stand for the Anthem. But as I do so I am standing for what the Anthem and the flag are all about: Freedom!

Monday, February 29, 2016

Super Tuesday is Coming!

You would think I could find something better to talk about on this leap day Monday than politics. Actually, I probably could, but tomorrow is another big day in the election year. Yes, all the media are hyping the possibilities and probabilities along with the odds and percentages of each candidate.

So far none of these "Big Days!" in the election cycle have proven to be decisive. Will tomorrow? Eh!

It would be nice if it did. We could settle down to less hype, although I doubt that would happen or bring about more discussion of issues. That is not happening in this election year. I don't see why things should change. What I have seen is that the "Establishment" of both parties is trying to figure out what to do with this runaway train of dissatisfaction that is threatening the very heart of both party machines.

Chris Christie supports Trump instead of Rubio and Lindsay Graham says that the GOP has gone "batshit crazy." Democrat pundits try to point out the errors in Bernie Sanders' logic, trying to undermine his apparent support. Trump continues to be Trump, what looks like an almost unstoppable ride to the nomination.

The rest of us sit on the sidelines and scratch our heads. I shake my head many times a day when I hear the news and ask

What in the world has happened to our system?
I know there have been mud fights like this before. I know that politics has never been a "let's sit down and discuss this like gentlemen" system. At least not when it comes to elections! (And yes, it was almost always men, so the gentlemen is not out of historical context.) But this year seems to have hit a new low, jumped the shark, or whatever superlative description you want to use.

Popular author and pastor Max Lucado did something new and unusual for him last week. He wrote an editorial piece that was published in the Washington Post calling for decency in the campaign. He cited Donald Trump's language and tactics and, rightly, I believe, said that such tactics wouldn't even be fit for a "middle-school election." All these things, Lucado said, are done with the Bible in one hand.

What became the "money quote" for me in the article was this paragraph:
The stock explanation for Mr. Trump’s success is this: He has tapped into the anger of the American people. As one man said, “We are voting with our middle finger.” Sounds more like a comment for a gang-fight than a presidential election. Anger-fueled reactions have caused trouble ever since Cain was angry at Abel.
Lucado has never made political statements in public before. He could not, I am sure, sit idly by with these.

Like Lucado I am looking around and seeing this anger-fueled election.  And if I think it's bad now, I don't believe we have seen the half of it. I received a robo-call the other day which sent shivers up my spine. It was from some person somewhere who claimed to be a "white nationalist" supporting Donald Trump because we are facing "white genocide" where "beautiful little white children" are being denigrated and killed. He even got in a non-named attack on "Cubans" who are running for president.

We have seen crazy memes on Facebook likening socialism (i.e. Bernie Sanders) to Hitler and Stalin with no awareness of history, politics, or economics. Hillary is easily depicted as the most foul and criminal person ever to run for president.

It is only the end of February. No matter who is nominated in either party, the general election will become a bloodbath of hatred, prejudice, and many other very difficult insinuations and downright declarations.

I can do nothing about it, I am afraid. All I can do is write these posts, send them off as words of hope that we can do something to avoid the pain of what we have been seeing. I am powerless.  Not a new idea for me as a recovering person. So in the end I find myself in that extremely difficult position of having strong opinions, strong fears, and a deep, heavy cloud of despair filling the election season around me.

When that happens all I can do is say the Serenity Prayer again.
God grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change;
courage to change the things I can;
and wisdom to know the difference.
I will continue to look for the ways I can do something, praying for the courage to stand up for those things, but also knowing that in the end all I can really do is write these posts, express my opinions, and then vote.

I promise I will at least do those.

Maybe we can hope that tomorrow some of this will find some resolution. Maybe we can begin to talk about some of this with a little more decency. I am not hopeful, at least about the public dialogue, however. But maybe, as we ponder these things and look into our own national soul, we can find a way to bring about the change in the election atmosphere that we need.

Saturday, January 30, 2016

Enough of a Horse Race

I have been watching the horse race and carnival sideshow we are generously calling the Presidential Election Campaign. All anyone seems to be interested in is:

  • Who's ahead? 
  • What are the polls saying? 
  • Can anyone beat Trump? 
  • Is Cruz that awful a person? 
  • Is Hillary going to tank again? 
  • Can Sanders be a socialist and still win?
That last question is as close to the issues as anyone in the press will go. And that's nothing but pulling a word out that will raise concerns and issues with voters. I am saddened, afraid, and downright upset about the whole process so far.

I know I have mentioned here before that I have been interested in politics since 1956 when, at age 8, my family's support for Adlai Stevenson was in  the minority in our north central Pennsylvania town. Politics hooked me as something interesting and important. The campaign of John F. Kennedy in 1960 settled my political addiction once and for all. I ended up a political science (government) major in college. I am a believer in voting rights being as important constitutionally important as gun rights or freedom of speech and the press.

In my study of history I also know that our campaigns have often been rabble-rousing affairs. The infamous John Adams-Thomas Jefferson election being among the slimiest, at least as far as name-calling and general truth-stretching.  In some ways, then, this particular election cycle has "fine pedigree" in our early history.

But I am not aware of any election cycle that could be considered as amateurish, mean, and so far off center as this one is. At least not at the presidential election level. There have been incompetent candidates at times. Some of them even got elected. But this one seems to be truly unique- one of a kind.
  • When issues are discussed, they result in sound bites that call for carpet-bombing of women and children or having Mexico pay for a wall to keep their citizens in. 
  • A reporter tells the story of how in most Trump rallies he points at the enclosure in the back where the media and reporters are kept and the crowd boos. Yet, it is that very media who is reporting and keeping him on top. 
  • A conservative magazine comes out with an issue of essay about why Trump isn't right for America.  
  • On the fringes someone has come up with the great view that Hitler was a left-wing liberal since he was a "socialist."  Therefore Bernie Sanders is like Hitler.
The party establishment of both parties is uncertain. Party hacks, both Democrat and Republican are afraid that if the non-establishment candidates get nominated they will lose. The political process has been hijacked by several different factors.
  • Anger
  • From the end of the 2008 election cycle, anger has been at the bottom of almost everything from the GOP. Hints of it have shown up before, but this is beyond anything we have seen in a long time. The extremely virulent opposition to Obama's presidency has been so deeply rooted in those against him they have wanted him to fail so they could take over. If he had succeeded- unthinkable to them!
  • Social media
  • What plays on social media? What gets attention? The mainstream media has been as much at fault in this as has been the biased media of Fox or MSNBC. Add the easily available presence of all kinds of opinions on Facebook and the Internet and you have an opening for any and all opinions to be expressed. Of course, most are preaching to their own kind, but their presence- and coverage in the press- only goes to flame the anger. No- I am not saying that we should limit any of these. Perhaps we need to discover that these views are the extremes- unwilling to compromise at any time with anybody. And that is not how democracy works.
  • Money
  • The Koch brothers are only the visible sign of the invisible evil of an oligarchy at work. Since Citizens United, corporate money has dominated. Here, from Wikipedia, is a way of looking at it:
    Plutocracy is a form of oligarchy and defines a society ruled or controlled by the small minority of the wealthiest citizens. The first known use of the term was in 1652. Unlike systems such as democracy, capitalism, socialism or anarchism, plutocracy is not rooted in an established political philosophy.
    Actually we seem to have developed two sides of this- the liberal plutocracy and the conservative plutocracy. These are the ones who fund and support the established orders. They were deprived of some of their historic power starting with Teddy Roosevelt's progressive reforms in the GOP in the early 20th Century and Franklin Roosevelt's with the Democrats in the 1930s and 40s. They have been working hard to gain it back- and are succeeding. They have convinced the greater population that "trickle-down" economics works and that "job-creators" deserve breaks in order to create jobs. Again, this is happening on both sides of the political spectrum. Part of the appeal of a Trump or a Sanders is that they present themselves as outside this system of support.
  • And did I mention anger and hate?
  • Add hate to the anger and you have a dangerous mixture. I would even go so far as to say racism is the final straw that has broken the political process.No one will ever convince me that the opposition to Obama's presidency was not fanned by racism. That does NOT mean that all of us whites are racists. Many who opposed Obama were not- and are not- racist. But there is an undercurrent of racism- systemic racism- that has been at work which then pulls in the interest of those who may truly be racist. I believe it took the election of a "liberal" African-American to bring it out. I also believe that some of the "birther" crap about Cruz stems from the same underlying Euro-centrism. Rubio as another Hispanic and Sanders as Jewish will face it if nominated.
So, in the next couple weeks we will see Iowa and then New Hampshire play a role far beyond their place in the American political scene. Anything can happen, of course, in either state. But it will not be based on substantive issues. Not at this point. Everything is too raw. We need some perspective, which has been sadly missing so far. I don't see it as getting any better.

Nor do I have any idea who will end up as the nominee of either party. Sanders, at this moment, has as good a chance as Hillary, who is on a potentially razor-thin edge. Trump and Cruz are certainly the most likely front runners, at this moment. I hope and pray that the tenor of this campaign will change, though history keeps me quite hopeless about that outcome.  But I also remember that Pat Robertson and Mike Huckabee have both won the Iowa caucuses in the past.

I have hunch it is going to be quite a ride.

Monday, December 14, 2015

Why This Is Important To Me

The 60s were just beginning. I was turning 12-years old. A Nazi war criminal was kidnapped in Argentina and transported to Israel where he was to stand trial. As a young boy with a Jewish mother it was the beginning of an awakening to the ways of the world. By the time I had my Bar Mitzvah at age 13 a year later the trial of Adolph Eichmann had raised awareness and renewed interest worldwide in The Holocaust.This was a new frightening reality to a 13-year old.

The Final Solution, the latest and arguably among the most terrible, awful, and horrific chapter of the 2000-year journey of the Jewish people facing persecution and anti-Semitism was out in the open. It is not something I have ever let slide from my memory. Even after I became a Christian just before turning 16 the awareness of The Holocaust stayed as real and as essential to my being as anything else.

Over the next couple decades I did a lot of reading and study on the issue of anti-Semitism and its history. If racism is the “original sin” of the United States, anti-Semitism is the “original sin” of western civilization and the Christian Church. Over these years I learned that

  • neither I, nor any children I might have would have been safe in Germany in World War II.
  • the anti-Jewish theological interpretations of many Christian writers and leaders from the early Church Fathers to Augustine then Martin Luther set the foundation for the hatred of the Jews.
  • the word “ghetto” was first used as the place where Jews were made to live so they wouldn’t contaminate good people, i.e. Christians.
  • perhaps the best and greatest era for many Jews was in Muslim Spain. Then when the Christians re-conquered Spain, the Jews were expelled- even Christians who had converted a generation or two earlier. (You can’t trust the Jews.)
When I got to Seminary I was introduced to the writings of people like Dietrich Bonhoeffer who stood up against the Nazis and died in a concentration camp. I learned of Martin Niemoller, a Lutheran pastor who stood up against the hatred and spent years in a camp. Both of them led a faction known as "The Confessing Church" making a clear distinction that they were not part of the "German Christians", the civil "official" religion of the day including leaders of the Evangelical and Catholic Churches.

For a number of years I regularly participated in an annual dialogue between Christians and Jews at Princeton Seminary. I had the fortune of hearing Elie Wiesel speak years before he was a Nobel Peace Prize winner. I put together a multi-media presentation based on the novel, Last of the Just, and developed several versions of a Passover Seder for my churches and others. I visited Israel and stood in overwhelmed silence at Yad Vashem. I am sadly and deeply aware of the complicity of the Christian Church in all of this and that the very foundation of this evil is in Christian theology. (That is for another time and place, though.)

In all these studies, readings, presentations and challenges, two things were at the core of what I learned.
  • Never Forget!
  • Never Again! 
 Not just about the Jewish people and anti-Semitism, but about persecution and oppression. If “they” could do this to others, “they” can do it to me, too. Martin Niemoller’s famous words were burned into my heart and soul:
First they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out—
Because I was not a Socialist.

Then they came for the Trade Unionists, and I did not speak out—
Because I was not a Trade Unionist.

Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—
Because I was not a Jew.

Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.
I have now been a Christian for nearly 54 years, almost 80% of my life. But I know that I am also "Jewish", the son of a Jewish mother. My "people" are Jewish and Gentile. Many of my "people" have been killed over the centuries by my other "people" in the name of a Jewish Rabbi from 1st Century Judea. Over these years I have promised myself that I would stand up for what is right when oppression and hatred are expressed. I have told myself that if need be, I should stand with the oppressed, even if I am part of the oppressors.

Scary stuff, then, when we see things happening in the world around us that looks so much like the evil we have faced down in the past. I have just finished a year of reviewing my Dad's service at the end of World War II. One of my discoveries was that his Division was a "liberating" unit at some camps in Germany. Whether he was part of a specific liberating group is unknown. That is what my Dad fought to end. How can I sit by and watch?

I will not stop speaking out about it. I cannot. There are all kinds of ways that we humans can justify evil and hatred- fear and protection being high on the list. That does not ever excuse it. Such discrimination is evil. Period.

Are we anywhere near that? No, not yet. I hope. But I am afraid yet hopeful. I love the United States and our freedoms. I believe that we are, at heart, good people. But good people can be subverted by those seeking to play on their fears and uncertainties. Good people can be made to do evil when they believe it is good. There were many good people in Germany in the 1930s before World War II. They were there during the war. Many of them did what they could in the face of their own possible deaths to help.

A Rabbi I talked with once when I was writing an independent project paper for seminary had been a prisoner in a concentration camp. Since he was an American he was kept aside for possible use in negotiations with the Americans. He reminded me a number of times that while the vicious and hateful guards were Germans, so were the guards who risked their lives to bring him an extra bit of food.

There are many good people in our country. When push comes to shove in this very difficult time, I am sure that we will do the right thing. If they would start to "register" Muslims there are many non-Muslims who will line up at the registration stations next to their neighbors. I pray that it doesn't come to that- and I don't believe it will. But we must no let those who would sow hatred and oppression have the final word. I will not be silent. I cannot be silent. There are far too many who have already been silenced by such hate.

And yes, that means that we also must stand against the evils of groups like ISIS or the Taliban. We must always call evil what it is. We can stand WITH our Muslim friends and neighbors, supporting them against the evil they are also fighting. 

Enough is enough.

Never again!

Silence in the face of evil is itself evil:
God will not hold us guiltless.
Not to speak is to speak.
Not to act is to act.
--Dietrich Bonhoeffer

Sunday, October 26, 2014

It's Just This Simple

Matthew 22:34-40-- When the Pharisees heard that he had silenced the Sadducees, they gathered together, and one of them, a lawyer, asked him a question to test him. “Teacher, which commandment in the law is the greatest?” He said to him, “’You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind.’ This is the greatest and first commandment. And a second is like it: ‘You shall love your neighbor as yourself.’ On these two commandments hang all the law and the prophets.”
Of course, simple doesn't mean easy. Why? Because we are humans who have been slow to learn this thing call loving your neighbor as yourself. Or, at least when it comes to defining who my neighbor is. But maybe we can get better at it. What I think will be more likely to enhance our ability to do so is to understand that in a world like ours, EVERYONE is our neighbor- and we each are everyone else's neighbor. The world-wide recession in the past six years shows that. The price of oil and its effect on gas prices AND food prices shows that. Even the world-wide terror alerts and the Ebola reactions show that.

Yet, Jesus was speaking something far more profound than we are willing to admit. We humans are community-based creatures. We need other humans to support us, protect us, raise our children. The simple fact of the long period of growth of human children and their powerlessness and helplessness is an indicator of that. When our primitive human ancestors started to form small bands or tribes, the movement toward community was begun.

But it was also the beginning of competition between tribes which only morphed (dare I say metastasized?) into states, nation-states and then mega-states. Suddenly the definitions of neighbor needed to be expanded- or identified differently. The result was the expansion of tribal conflict into war, into global war. As I mentioned in one of my posts on the 10th Armored Division in World War II the number of people involved in that conflict was staggering. There were 1.9 billion people impacted by the war. That is an amazing 90% of the world population in 1941!

Who says we are not all neighbors?

Certainly not Jesus. He broke all those neighbor taboos from women to Samaritans to children to lepers to those possessed to Romans to tax collectors to the poor to orphans to those in prison to those caught in adultery. In short, he broke the taboos by making all of the known enemies of the day his neighbors. What is kind of scary to me is that the only group he was less-friendly with - the religious and political leaders. (That I will just let sit there. Make your own determinations of that one. At least for today.)

The challenge I hear from Jesus in this hate-filled world in this time of fear and finger-pointing is to take a different look at the enemies we put on our hate list. Until we can treat them with love, we are not living up to our name as Christians. I hear Jesus telling me to pray for them- and to pray that we ourselves may be blessed by them. It is a two-way street.

Wednesday, May 30, 2012

Dangerous Times

Live Science had a good article the other day about the dangers of such deep political polarization as we are seeing happen now.

Traditionally, political parties have been coalitions of broad groups of people, based more on industry, region and interest group than basic morals, University of Virginia psychologist Jonathan Haidt said here during a lecture at the annual meeting of the Association of Psychological Science. Since the 1970s and 1980s, however, Americans have increasingly sorted themselves by liberalism and conservatism, resulting in two political parties that seem almost alien to one another. (Link)
I was struck last week by some of the incredible rhetoric on the polarized talking heads shows (Fox and MSNBC). No one, even those I agreed with, seemed willing to tone it down. Everyone is yelling; everyone is finger pointing. Any disagreement, even within your own party is seen as giving aid and comfort to the enemy.

This is not the politics I studied in college. This is not the political process of democracy's finest hours.

Then Professor Haidt's money quote:
When politics are tied inextricably to morals, everything becomes sacred, from guns to flags to race. And when sacred values are threatened, people lash out. Debates are no longer disagreement, they're treason. (Link)
Here's that last sentence again. Read it with sadness and even worry about where we might go between now and November's election:
Debates are no longer disagreement, they're treason.

Friday, March 11, 2011

A Sad Headline

Hearings on the radicalization of Muslim Americans

Sad.

Even completely antithetical to the American way of life and the very values we hold to be self-evident.

A headline based on fear of the different and the other.

A headline that takes one whole group of people and lumps them together.

What about the radicalization of poor whites in the last century- by the KKK?

What about the radicalization of Jews after WW II as many sought for a homeland in Palestine?

What about the radicalization of Irish-Americans by the IRA in the middle of the last century?

Try any of those headlines and you will have a political storm on your hands.

But we demonize Muslim-Americans because a few deranged people in the Middle East planned a horrific attack.

I had thought that after the end of WW II, when we were challenged by the internment camps for Japanese-Americans, we might have a little more sense.

I guess we are still a work in progress.

Pray for wisdom and insight that we can live out our values.