Friday, September 21, 2018
Monday, July 17, 2017
Can a Law be Unethical?
Traditionally there are four basic principles of medical ethics:
- Autonomy
- The right of the individual to self-determination.
- Informed consent is basic to health care.
- Do no harm. (Non-maleficence)
- Actions should not be the cause of harm.
- In practice, don't be hasty and do thorough evaluation.
- Do good. (Beneficence)
- Actions that promote the well-being of others.
- Needs of the patient come first.
- Justice and Respect for Human Rights
- Fair and equitable distribution of scarce resources
- Respect for the rights of each as a person.
Yes, a law can be unethical. Unethical does not mean illegal. We do not need to go to extremist countries to find laws that were unethical- at best- and inhumane at worst. Laws of segregation in the post-reconstruction South in the United States were not illegal. They were the law. But we know they were certainly unethical in spite of the ways they were justified. Eventually they were seen as "unconstitutional" which made them "illegal." But it took legal interpretations and arguments to get to that point.
I hope someone will take a hard ethical look at the proposed health care reform law in the Senate. Yes, there are conflicting needs and wants. There are questions, for example, about equitable distribution of resources.
- But will the new law cause harm?
- Will it be just and respectful of the life and dignity of individuals?
- Will it promote doing what supports the well being of others?
- Will it support the autonomy of all patients and their right to medical care?
Posted by pmPilgrim
Labels: ethics, health care, Mayo Family, medical ethics, Quotes 0 comments
Monday, March 07, 2016
Calendar of Saints: Mayo and Meninger Families
Periodically I post a quote from a saint from the Episcopal Calendar of Saints that week. I connect it with a picture that I have taken as a kind of poster. These are meant to be meditative and mindful, playful and thought inducing. I hope they are helpful in your spiritual journeys.
Mayo and Meninger Families
Pioneers in Medicine
March 6
William Worrall Mayo (May 31, 1819 – March 6, 1911) was an English born medical doctor and chemist, best known for establishing the private medical practice that later evolved into the Mayo Clinic. His sons, William James Mayo and Charles Horace Mayo, joined the private practice in Rochester, Minnesota in the 1880s.
William James Mayo (June 29, 1861 – July 28, 1939) was a physician in the United States and one of the seven founders of the Mayo Clinic. He and his brother, Charles Horace Mayo, both joined their father's private medical practice in Rochester, Minnesota, USA, after graduating from medical school at the Univ. of Michigan in 1883. In 1919, this private medical practice became the not-for-profit Mayo Clinic.
Charles Horace Mayo (July 19, 1865 – May 26, 1939) was an American medical practitioner and was one of the founders of the Mayo Clinic along with his brother, William James Mayo, and others. He graduated from the medical school of Northwestern University (now called the Feinberg School of Medicine) in 1888 and joined his father, William Worrall Mayo, and older brother, William James Mayo, in their private medical practice in Rochester.
The Mayo Clinic came to be regarded as one of the foremost medical treatment and research institutions in the world. Within Mayo's lifetime it registered one million patients. The idea of medical specialization was developed by this group of medical pioneers.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Charles F. Menninger (July 11, 1862 - Nov. 28, 1953), with his two sons, founded the Menninger Clinic in 1925 in Topeka, Kansas. This was one of the first places which sought to treat psychiatric maladies as illnesses which could be cured, rather than simply providing custodial care. ... He sought collaboration with local Topeka doctors, who tended to reject him due to his homeopathic background. As a consequence, he became enamored of collaborative group practice, such as he saw at the Mayo Clinic. This would later strongly influence his own clinic.
Karl Augustus Menninger (July 22, 1893 - July 18, 1990), born in Topeka, Kansas, was an American psychiatrist and a member of the famous Menninger family of psychiatrists who founded the Menninger Foundation and the Menninger Clinic in Topeka, Kansas.
William Claire Menninger (Oct. 15, 1899 - Sept. 6, 1966) was a co-founder with his brother Karl and his father of The Menninger Foundation in Topeka, Kansas.
Personal note: I am humbled to be employed by the Mayo Clinic with its rich history of health care innovation. The spirit of the Mayo Family continues to be felt strongly throughout the clinic's work. I also remember Karl Menninger and his influence on many of us entering ministry in the 1970s thanks to his amazing book, Whatever Became of Sin?, published in 1973. Google Books says:
Menninger's renowned book questions what is wrong with our ethics, values and morality and asserts that the answers lie within ourselvesPerhaps it is time to re-read that and see if it holds up to 43 years.
Posted by pmPilgrim
Labels: health care, Mayo Clinic, Mayo Family, medicine, Menninger Clinic, Menninger Family, mental health, photography, Quotes, Saints 0 comments
Thursday, July 30, 2015
A Last Minute Post
Well, last minute in the sense that I am actually writing this just prior to posting it. Most of my work on the blog is, by nature, done ahead of time. That way it doesn't become a rush to get something written and posted at the last minute before midnight.
But because of scheduling up ahead of me over the next 10 days, I knew that if I waited to post these thoughts, it might be "old news."
So I decided to post this one today. That way it really is current events.
- It's about that lion in Africa and the Minnesota dentist who paid $50,000 to have it lured from a sanctuary so he could shoot it with a bow and arrow then track it for 40-hours in its agony and then kill it.
- It's also about the Cincinnati university police officer who has been arraigned for murder in a traffic stop gone bad.
- It's about the insanity of the alleged Planned Parenthood videos that purport to show that the organization is a venal, baby-killing group out to make money from fetuses.
- It's about the presidential [sic] candidates calling Mexicans rapists and accusing the sitting president of leading Jews to the ovens over a nuclear arms deal.
- It's about denying climate change because it will hurt business and profits to do otherwise and the hell with the health of the planet.
- It's about having to have 30+ women claim to be raped by a well-known celebrity- and even then saying it didn't happen until his own words describe exactly what they have claimed.
What got me started was seeing the incredible world-wide and national reaction to the lion killing. The reaction was far beyond that for any of the other killings we are hearing about. The reaction to a lion (and I AM an animal conservationist!), even a "famous" and protected lion, raises more anger than much else that is REAL news. Every time three is a mass killing somewhere in the country we are told to pray and NOT politicize. Yet every killing like that does have a political side to it. We are told to remember that all lives matter, not just black lives, even when it is the black lives that seem to be of far less value in how, when, and where they are killed.
Yes, all lives matter, and THEREFORE,
- all black lives matter, and when they are being killed in traffic stops or as the result of incredibly far-fetched traffic stops, THEY matter and we need to pay attention.
- the lives of billions on the planet matter when we are facing potentially catastrophic changes to our environment that will put those lives in severe jeopardy.
- the lives of the Israelis and the lives of millions of others in the Middle East matter enough to work hard at preventing nuclear weapons from continuing to proliferate and putting all of them at risk.
- women who have been raped,
- veterans who have been denied health services,
- poor people who can't get health care,
- police officers who are under incredible pressures and need better support, stress assistance and training for their difficult jobs,
- bullied gay youth,
- the mentally ill who are seen as crazy and to be held in contempt,
- prisoners in overcrowded prisons that are filled with non-violent offenders incarcerated because they possessed marijuana
- the immigrants who, like most of OUR OWN ancestors are here to build the American dream and rape and pillage?
- Pray for peace
- Work for peace
- Uphold peace
- Make peace a reality
- Live peace each day
Let's live today as if each person we meet has a life that matters and then treat them that way.
Posted by pmPilgrim
Labels: Gay, guns, health care, killings, mental health, Middle East, murder, News, nuclear weapons, peace, prisoners, racism, rape, War, women 0 comments
Tuesday, November 18, 2014
Fearing What We Don't Know
One of the stories on NPR's All Things Considered today had this headline:
A new poll shows Ebola is the one of the top health concerns of Americans, below access to health care and affordable health care.It ranks third, to be exact, according to the story, behind access to health care and the cost of health care. Then, dropping down behind Ebola as a top health concern- cancer and obesity. My first reaction was one of utter amazement. A disease that has infected exactly two people in the United States is a top health concern. Two people, both of whom are now healthy.
My second reaction was the title of this post. Ebola is scary because it is new and quite unknown. We have learned to live in denial about the major health concerns in the country- cancer, heart disease, obesity. We have learned to completely ignore alcoholism and addiction as health crises and place them as legal issues.
Anything to keep from having to deal with the health implications. Denial is a fine thing.
Well, the story went on to posit one other thought that didn't come immediately to mind, namely what happens when people are given open-ended questions like this one. What is the biggest health concern facing the US today? No choices to make, just think about it and what comes to mind?
As the researcher said, when we are given that question, we are more affected by what is making the news today than what might be the real and most significant health concern. Guess what? Name the big health care stories of the past few weeks.
- The Affordable Care Act (access to and cost of health care) and
- the Ebola concerns.
A helluva way to run public policy, though. But it is where we are today.
Posted by pmPilgrim
Labels: health care, News, politics 0 comments
Thursday, July 31, 2014
Dedication
Listening to BBC on public radio the other afternoon, the amazing dedication of health care workers in difficult situations was brought home. They were interviewing a volunteer worker who has just returned from West Africa and the Ebola Virus outbreak. She had just described the horrors- medically, physically, and psychologically of the situation. She reported on her own nightmares she has been experiencing since returning. She talked about the graphic awfulness of the scenes and the upheaval in so many lives.
The interviewer then asked, expecting an obvious answer, "Would you even consider going back there into the midst of all that?"
"In a heartbeat,"was the immediate answer.
The interviewer was flabbergasted. So was I.
Amazing dedication. These workers are amazing.
Posted by pmPilgrim
Labels: dedication, health care, News 0 comments
Wednesday, October 14, 2009
Finding What You Want to Know
The other evening I was in a discussion with an acquaintance about the health care reform debate. He was clearly against whatever it is that President Obama is trying to do. He had all the standard complaints we have heard from the opponents, a number of which have been refuted a number of times. Surprisingly he claimed to not think much of the right-wing pundits- Beck, Limbaugh, and O'Really.
Which is why I was surprised when he voiced the claim that the health care reform legislation isn't public and that the Democrats/Obama are hiding it from people so they won't know what's in it. Surprised? I was flabbergasted. I looked at him and commented that I know that it was over 40 years ago that I was a government/poli sci major but I didn't think the Congress had changed that much.
But he wasn't kidding. He challenged me. You won't find it on the Internet, he claimed. It's secret. I again tried to explain that Congress doesn't vote on non-existent legislation. He didn't back down and challenged me. You wont' find it, he insisted.
Well, at home that evening, it took me an extremely long time, oh, about 45 seconds, to find it. Both versions. The one passed by the Health Committee and the one passed by the Finance Committee.
All you have to do is go to senate.gov and look at active legislation. Or to the committees link and either Finance or Health and Education (H.E.L.P.) It's right there. All 200+ pages in .pdf format.
Senate bill S. 1679 or House bill H.R. 3200 Note that's seven links in that one paragraph to something to supposedly is being kept secret. And there are probably more but I ran out of time after five minutes of searching and some reading.
Then this morning I noticed on Yahoo! News that they headlined that the health bill is now back "behind closed doors." NO! I wanted to shout. That does not mean what many will say. It does mean that they are back there doing political machinations to fool us all. Read the article and you know that it means that there are two bills reported out of the two committees and a conference committee is now hammering out the differences for one bill to come to the floor. No wonder we don't know what to think when the news media puts headlines that confuse more than clarify.
All this reminded me of the U.S. Civics quiz online that showed how little people know about how our government works.
Seventy-one percent of Americans fail the test, with an overall average score of 49%.It only continues to show me that the debates we are having about a number of issues, but at this moment, particularly the health care debate, is based as much on fear and misinformation than on the facts- death panels being the one obvious bit of incorrect information that even Senators who should know, aren't refuting for political gain.
* Liberals score 49%; conservatives score 48%. Republicans score 52%; Democrats score 45%.
* Fewer than half of all Americans can name all three branches of government, a minimal requirement for understanding America’s constitutional system.
[Note that these scores are regardless of affiliation or ideology.]
I am saddened by the whole process that we are in. Somewhere in the past 20 years we have lost a sense of discussion and the ability to work with people we may disagree with to find solutions. "Just say 'No!' " is not a solution. On either side. Politics is about compromise. On both sides.
This health care debate and reform is important. Celebrate and strengthen what is working and working well. Reform what isn't and help more people be covered by insurance. In an industrialized, advanced civilized country it is unforgivable that people lose health insurance when they lose a job or die because they can't get insurance. There are basics of a caring compassionate civilization that are essential. In some way we have to see that this happens.
But we have to get the facts and not the hysteria.
Posted by pmPilgrim
Labels: health care, politics 1 comments
Wednesday, August 19, 2009
Bad Idea? Good Idea? Fair Compromise?
I have waited a couple of days since the announcement about the health care compromise that might get rid of the "public option."
My first reaction: No way! There is no reform without some way to insure the uninsured. It remains worse than a scandal that people can go bankrupt because they get sick or lose their jobs and hence their insurance. And how many of the people who are against the public option are willing to take Medicare and Social Security?
My second reaction: It's not the right way. Again, the scandal of the uninsured looms over the whole issue. But I can begin to see why it might have some short-term political value. Yes, maybe the "public option" needs some tweaking, but we need something. It is essential.
My third reaction: Well, maybe. If we have to. It's better than killing the whole bill and it may bring the Democrats in Congress together enough to pass it.
But if he thinks it will ease the Republican campaign against it- not a chance. We are not talking about bi-partisan compromise here. Not in your life. A few moderate Republicans who already are generally in favor will now be more certain. The conservative Democrats will jump on board. But the others will stay just as locked into their anti-Obama approach as ever. Probably even more so as they may not get what they want.
So, I realize I may have to live with it, but someone absolutely needs to do some serious work on the issue. The "co-op" idea will work as well as insurance has. And if anyone believes we don't have medical rationing by the insurance industry now, just try and get something if you are outside the box.
In short, the least and the lost will be the ones hurt by this compromise. I for one am deeply saddened by that. Let us not forget them.
Posted by pmPilgrim
Labels: health care, politics 0 comments
Tuesday, April 07, 2009
Faces of a Tragedy
I wrote a couple weeks ago about an interview on public radio which talked about a nation that allows people to die because they lose their job- and health insurance.
This past Sunday 60 Minutes on CBS put faces to that terrible situation. They titled it "The Clinic is Closed" as they chronicled what as happened in Las Vegas since the only public hospital in the state, UMC, closed a number of services due to loss of income.
The story was painful. You get cancer, you lose your job, you lose your insurance. Then you lose your treatment. Sounds like a death sentence.
As one person commented you never think about these things when you are well. You kind of just expect things to be taken care of because they always have been. Without significant health reform we will become a country where people die because they lose their insurance. And they lose their insurance simply because they lose their job.
I repeat what I said two weeks ago: What kind of country do we want to call home?
Posted by pmPilgrim
Labels: health care 0 comments
Friday, March 20, 2009
Health Care Reform
Economist and Princeton professor Uwe Reinhardt was on Fresh Air with Terry Gross last week. Some of what he said really hit home and expressed my gut feelings about why health care reform is not an option. He was talking about the simple fact that in a nation like ours it is unthinkable that people who need health care won't get it because they can't afford insurance.
Here are some quotes from the last part of the interview when Reinhardt got passionate.
You lose your job, you lose your income, you lose your health insurance. It's an accident of World War II that we have it the way we it is...I had never heard someone put it so personally, passionately and succinctly. I had never had someone ask that powerful question:
I grew up in a tool shed and I know how good it was that when we were paupers we had health insurance like everyone else in Germany. I would like the American people to have what I had as a kid.
Stay away from people who try to solve with cliches, ike this is socialized medicine and then you don't have to think about it anymore. Try to think through- what kind of country would you like to live in? Do you want to live in a country where someone who loses his job loses his insurance?
Do you want a system where kids get out of college and can't get insurance for ten years?
Do you want it that when a family member gets cancer you lose house or car?
We have that now. Lose insurance with job, lose house and go bankrupt over medical bills. No one in Canada or Germany has that happen.
What kind of country do you want to live in?
What kind of country do we want to live in?Some have criticized President Obama over his trying to tackle health care (and other issues) when the financial crisis is so deep. Well, as unemployment goes up, as more people are out of work, as income goes down for many, they can't afford health care. That is not an idle issue separate from others.
The health care system is as important to our national economy as auto or finance. (In some places like here in Rochester, MN, it is the center of our economy.) So what happens....
- All of a sudden more people don't have insurance.
- They don't go to the doctor for important check-ups.
- They get sick and go to a clinic or emergency room.
- They can't pay but rightly get treated.
- The institution eats the cost or gets minor reimbursement.
- The health care system loses money. They cut back on services or employees.
- And the cycle continues.
What kind of country do we want to call home?
I don't know what such a system would look like. There are far more brilliant minds than mine working on it. Health care systems are working on it because they are already seeing the early signs. It is part of the spiral of recession and needs to be ready to be handled well, or we will all pay the price- literally with our health, the health of our children and communities, and the health of our nation.
Posted by pmPilgrim
Labels: health care, News 1 comments
Tuesday, March 03, 2009
Some Reflections
Looking back to surgery several ideas still strike me.
- First was the fact that it takes a lot, repeat A LOT of support of all kinds to get you into, through, and out of surgery.
Then there were three nurses, the surgeon's nurse, the resident, and two anesthesiologists while in pre-op. It was the anesthesiologist who put my IV in and then took me to the OR. Now we are at 13 people.
I was aware of how relatively small the OR was. Since I was only having a relatively easy back surgery I guess the bigger size wasn't needed. While I was still awake in the OR there was a technician working on some wire connections at the wall at my feet and another technician getting things ready. That brought the total to 15. Then came the first drugs and ....
So that means for little old me there were 15 people involved in my care before surgery even started. How many were there with the doctor and then to take me back to the (now) post-op and finally to my room? No idea but I can vaguely remember three at the end. Not including the doctor and the actual OR staff, that came to 18 different people in the 6 hours between walking in the hospital and going to my room.
I know that there are 8 operating rooms in the neurosurgery hallway and 60 overall in the hospital. Being conservative if even half of those were empty (doubtful) that could mean a minimum of 30 operations with a minimum of 18 people taking care of those in the ORs. That would be 540 people at work in direct support of all the little old people like me.
(Not included would be the maintenance staff cleaning up the pre-op for turning it into a post-op, hallway cleanliness, computer techs, etc. etc.)
No wonder it costs so much for quality health care! It takes people- and people cost money. I for one wouldn't want to cut any of that. I for one am grateful that there are people who can do these kinds of jobs and take care of all the little old people like me. Who is qualified to decide who gets what kind of care? Who is ready to play God in those situations? Insurance companies do a lot of that. Doctors sure don't want to play that role. Government shouldn't be making those decisions.
No wonder it's such a quagmire of politics.
- The second reflection was the electronic support all this took. Lying on the gurney in the pre-op room I could see all the wires and tubes coming out of the back of the station at my bedside. That was one of at least 30 stations in the area used for both pre- and post-op. And it connects to the whole system throughout the hospital. It is why today more is being done more quickly and efficiently than ever before.
More thoughts as they come
Posted by pmPilgrim
Labels: health care, personal, surgery 0 comments


